Page Content Begins Here
> Sign up for free or sign in and get exclusive rewards <


All-Time MLB All-Star Lineup Mock Draft | JustBats vs. JustGloves

all time mlb all star game lineup

The MLB All Star Game is the only game of the year where we, the fans, get a chance to see the best players in the world take the same field. But we wanted to take it a step further. We wanted to take the limitations of time out of the equation. We thought to ourselves, what if you could assemble an all-time All Star team?

So, that’s exactly what we did. Live on Instagram, JustBats and JustGloves drafted their all-time All Star squads. If you’re interested in the drafting process, we have the ~30 minute video below:

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by JustBats (@justbats)

JustBats All-Time Lineup

Taking an all-out power approach, Tyler assembled one of the most potent lineups imaginable. Loaded with all six of the top-six career HR leaders, including one on the bump, the JustBats squad is a who’s who among all-time hitters.

JustBats All-Time MLB All-Star Game Lineup

JustGloves All-Time Lineup

On the other side of the diamond, Ben chose to liter the field with gritty, athletic ballplayers. Led by one of the greatest postseason pitchers in baseball history (Madison Bumgarner) it’d be hard to imagine a scenario where this team loses in a one-game scenario.

JustGloves All-Time MLB All-Star Game Lineup

So… Who Wins?

Now it’s up to you to decide which team wins in a matchup between these two all-time squads. Does the power from JustBats ultimately prove to be too much? Or does the balance and athleticism push JustGloves over the top? You tell us. Hit us up on social media and let us know!


We hope that you’ve enjoyed our all-time MLB All-Star Game team mock draft and were able to get some inspiration for your own team. Also, if ever have any questions about baseball gloves or softball gloves, you can contact our Glove Experts at 866-321-4568, by email at or through our live chat. We're JustGloves and we're with you from Click To Catch!

Show Comparison
4.9 Star Rating, Google Customer Reviews